Showing posts with label consumer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label consumer. Show all posts

Monday, February 6, 2012

A housing update -- at best a flat market

Over the last few years during conversations with clients I've frequently been asked my opinion about the housing market and whether now is a good time to buy.  Home prices are naturally a point of conversation as they are a large part of most people's net worth and the loss of equity is preventing some people from moving up or refinancing.  So the question of whether we are at the bottom of home prices is an important one.  Unfortunately I don't think we are at the absolute bottom of home prices and we will most likely continue to see a slow decline in prices in the near future.  My non-prediction for 2012 is we will not see a rebound in home prices; at best we'll see a flat to slightly down market.

Home prices have strong local factors so this conversation is about national trends, your local market will vary.

Unfortunately right now home prices are continuing their decline nationwide:
Home prices still dropping - (Source: Paper Money)


Outstanding mortgages still contracting
Mortgage loan balance still declining
There are several headwinds the housing market needs to overcome before it is fully healed. This chart shows the change in mortgage values outstanding since 1975 (Source: Federal ReserveLooking at loan balances to predict home prices may seem counter intuitive but remember a rising total national loan balance means there are more buyers (and borrowers) entering the market.  Some interesting aspects of this chart are how even during other previous recessions (shown in gray) the value of outstanding mortgages continued to rise on a year over year basis; until our most recent recession in 2008/2009.  This was the first time during this entire data series when the total value of all mortgages outstanding declined on a year over year basis. One would not be engaging in hyperbole to call our current decline in home prices exceptional.

An overhang of foreclosed homes
While it appears the primary wave of home foreclosures is past us there still is a large backlog of homes in the foreclosure process. Until this backlog is completely cleared and returns to more 'normal' levels, the amount of housing coming on the market by 3rd parties (not the person who currently lives/owns the home) will put downward pressure on prices.

Single family delinquency rate (Source: CalculatedRisk)

Another negative factor is the hidden inventory of homes out there from people who want to move up or out but are waiting until home prices stabilize before putting the place on the market. I personally know of a few people who are accidental landlords and are hoping and waiting until prices stabilize before putting their rentals on the market.  While this is purely anecdotal I'm sure its not just a local or isolated phenomenon.

Renting versus Owning coming into balance
Fortunately there are some positive factors which should mitigate a continued decline in home prices.  Home prices and mortgage rates have declined to the point where a mortgage now equal to rent.
Rent versus Owning (Source: Soberlook)
As you can see for a very long time it was cheaper to rent versus own. We are approaching a point where this may invert and owning a home would be cheaper than renting. There are other upkeep and time costs associated with home ownership (as a homeowner I can assure you there are many!) but the primary costs are approaching parity.  

Clearing the excess inventory
The number of unsold homes is beginning to stabilize as a percentage of US population.  The hidden inventory is of course hard to measure but at least we are getting closer to 'normal' for this data series
Unsold homes as % of population - (Source: Sober Look)

The long decline in construction spending does appear to be finally over which will help the building trade and stop being a drag on overall GDP growth.
Construction finally bottoming? (Source: Federal Reserve)

Even though the housing market decline appears to be slowing forecasting when we finally reach bottom is not something I'm willing to predict right now. I believe the worst of the declines are behind us so if you are looking for a home now would be a good time to start looking but be picky and drive a hard bargain! There is going to be lots of supply coming on the market over the next few years.

One aspect of the crushing decline in home prices is it has popped the speculative mindset so very prevalent in American thinking a few years ago. (I'll admit to falling a little under that spell myself)  Take your time and find a house to live in, not one for profit.

Additional reading:
http://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2012/01/fannie-mae-serious-delinquency-rate.html
http://soberlook.com/2012/01/two-data-points-on-us-housing.html
http://paper-money.blogspot.com/2012/01/new-home-sales-december-2011.html
http://soberlook.com/2012/01/five-reasons-2012-will-be-start-of-us.html
http://paper-money.blogspot.com/2012/01/radar-watching-november-2011.html
http://paper-money.blogspot.com/2012/01/fhfa-monthly-home-prices-november-2011.html
http://paper-money.blogspot.com/2012/01/radar-watching-november-2011.html
http://pragcap.com/why-home-prices-have-much-further-to-fall
http://www.tilsonfunds.com/JohnBurnshousing.pdf
http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?graph_id=62720&category_id=4082
http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?graph_id=64527&category_id=4082
Calculated Risk calls a housing bottom
http://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2012/02/housing-bottom-is-here.html

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Bank lending update

It's been a few months since I last highlighted total bank lending but not much has changed since late October. Just to make sure you don't think I forgot here's an update.

Total bank loans and leases as per the Fed continues its steady decline economic recovery notwithstanding.  As you can see there was a large recent spike but this was due to an accounting change in bank's loans and not a sudden increase in lending.  This lack of new lending may be one reason broad money supply is so sluggish of late.

Like last update the banks are buying US Treasuries instead of lending. If you wondering who is buying those hated T bonds look to your corner mega-huge bank.   Considering their funding costs and capital requirements are pretty much zero you could say banks would rather just play golf and clip Treasury coupons.

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

Consumer credit update

Consumer credit data was recently released and the deleveraging continues.  This time I've shown the change in consumer credit over the entire data series so one can see how infrequently consumer credit declines.

The rate of decline is turning around, or so it seems.

This next graph shows a slightly different story (Thanks to @dafowc of declineandfallofwesterncivilization.blogspot.com)

Remove lending by Sallie Mae and the Federal government and the rate of decline has not been arrested.  Furthermore you can see this is a new phenomenon.

Very curious . . .  

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Bank lending update

The data initially looks good but a change in accounting rules is the reason and not more lending by the banks.


In Chart #1 you can see the recent large spike in total loans and leases at commercial banks.  New accounting rules forced the banks to place off balance sheet items back on their books.  (I thought the Enron scandal fixed all that? Guess not)


This really throws off the year over year data so don't get excited if you hear bank lending has recently surged.


Just to show you how this decline in lending is unusual Chart #2 shows the series longer term on a year over year change.  As you can see until recently serious declines in lending never happened.


In case you are wondering what the banks are buying instead of lending... they are buying US government securities.
In my opinion this lack of lending by the banks is just one reason the Fed is freaked out and is prepping the markets for QE 2.0.  They are going to flood the market with money to try to get more people to borrow money and buy stuff.  Unfortunately I don't think it will work and I'll be writing about that soon(tm)









Friday, October 15, 2010

Consumers and Credit -- Behaviors may not be changing

One item I follow are aggregate debt levels as well as additional focus on the consumer as they are a large portion of GDP.

A WSJ blog entry from Sept 18 caught my eye and the results of their analysis are very interesting.

Their conclusion is the consumer is not voluntarily deleveraging, rather it is from charge-off and defaults.  This information does synch with how retail sales continue slowly rising even in the face of declining credit. 

From the WSJ:

There are two ways, though, that the debts can decline: People can pay off existing loans, or they can renege on the loans, forcing the lender to charge them off. As it happens, the latter accounted for almost all the decline. Our own analysis of data from the Fed and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. suggests that over the two years ending June 2010, banks and other lenders charged off a total of about $588 billion in mortgage and consumer loans.
That means consumers managed to shave off only $22 billion in debt through the kind of belt-tightening we typically envision. In other words, in the absence of defaults, they would have achieved an annualized decline of only 0.08%.


Interesting data providing for very different conclusions. People will shop until their credit cards are pried from their cold dead fingers.

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

Foreclosure mess update: Why this is important

Barry Ritholtz clearly explains why this foreclosure mess is so important and how all the cutting of corners by the loan servicing organization has gotten completely out of control.

http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/2010/10/why-foreclosure-fraud-is-so-dangerous-to-property-rights/

I could try to paraphrase it but you really must read it ALL to understand why this scandal is more than just some 'goofed up paperwork'

http://www.marketwatch.com/story/bank-of-america-halts-all-foreclosure-wsj-2010-10-08?siteid=bnbh
Bank of America halts all foreclosures.  This is a few days old but just the latest in a long march of banks who are calling a full halt to foreclosures.

BofA's sterling efficiency is demonstrated by them foreclosing on a house with no mortgage. Whoops!
http://www.businessweek.com/news/2010-10-07/man-who-had-no-mortgage-faced-foreclosure-anyway-ann-woolner.html

This is going to get worse before it gets better . . .

Monday, October 11, 2010

Initial unemployment claims - Treading water

While I touched on initial unemployement claims before in an attempt to see if Google Trends could accurately predict changes, (failure!)  other people have shown the change in initial unemployment claims provides some predictive value. Creditwritedowns writes about how looking at the year over year change in unemployement claims provides insight into changes in consumer spending in America.   In short, a year over year decline in initial unemployment claims forebodes postive growth in the economy.

Let us take a look at the data (Source: Federal Reserve)


Looking at the year over year percent change in initial unemployement claims all appears well. The year over year number is negative meaning fewer people are getting laid off each week. 

There is a problem with this prognosis however and you can see it looking at the absolute numbers in the second graph. In chart two initial unemployment claims have remained quite stubborn for 2010, refusing to drop below the ~440k number for the entire year.   In a couple months if unemployment claims don't start falling our year over year metric will flatten out.  Right now the employement situation is treading water and this meshes well with the general sluggish feel to the economy.  

Right now this economic indicator is flashing Yellow.

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Foreclosure mess roundup

I have not commented on the foreclosure mess but considering how it may impact you, gentle reader, I thought it worthwhile to repeat.

In short, the mortgage processors and servicers did not keep a proper chain of custody and MBS Pool 'C' which believes they own the mortgage does not have the paperwork proving they purchased it from Loan Company 'A' which sold it to 'B', who packaged it up into MBS (Mortgage backed security) 'C', and Bank 'D' now owns said MBS.

Some people along that chain over ownership have been caught forging paperwork.  It's a long and nasty tale that will remain stuck in the courts for a while.

If you know of someone who is going through foreclosure and they want to keep the house this is something to keep in mind. Talk to a lawyer about ensuring the bank has all the proper paperwork.


From the WSJ, October 4
First, the affidavits IndyMac used to file the foreclosure were signed by a so-called robo-signer named Erica A. Johnson-Seck, who routinely signed 6,000 documents a week related to foreclosures and bankruptcy. That volume, the court decided, meant Ms. Johnson-Seck couldn't possibly have thoroughly reviewed the facts of Mr. Machado's case, as required by law.

Secondly, IndyMac (now called OneWest Bank) no longer owned the loan—a group of investors in a securitized trust managed by Deutsche Bank did. Determining that IndyMac didn't really have standing to foreclose, a judge threw out the case and ordered IndyMac to pay Mr. Machado's $30,000 legal bill.

From Bloomberg, October 4
Citigroup Inc. and Ally Financial Inc. units were sued by homeowners in Kentucky for allegedly conspiring with Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems Inc. to falsely foreclose on loans. The homeowners claim the defendants filed or caused to be filed mortgages with forged signatures, filed foreclosure actions months before they acquired any legal interest in the properties and falsely claimed to own notes executed with mortgages.
Video from NBC Nightly News, October 1
http://www.mefeedia.com/video/33073666

Calculatedrisk blog:
http://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2010/10/nightly-mortgage-mess.html


Nakedcapitalism has posted several entries regarding this topic.  Here's just one entry:
Lender Processing Services, a crucial player in the residential mortgage servicing arena, has been hit with two suits seeking national class action status (see here and here for the court filings). If the plaintiffs prevail, the disgorgement of fees by LPS could easily run into the billions of dollars (we have received a more precise estimate from plaintiffs’ counsel). To give a sense of proportion, LPS’s 2009 revenues were $2.4 billion and its net income that year was $276 million.
Here's one MSNBC Video on the mess:


I don't do this nasty tale of cutting corners and deception any justice with this overview. Read all the links above for a fuller story. 

Monday, July 26, 2010

Consumer credit keeps rolling downhill.

Earlier this month the Fed released the consumer credit data for May.  Total consumer credit keeps rolling downhill with no sign of slowing down.  I've included a longer term year over year chart as well as a more recent graph showing total consumer credit outstanding.

As you can see from this longer term year over year chart a sustained decline in lending has not occurred since this data series began at the end of World War II.  This is just one example of how this recession is different than all other post WWII slowdowns.

Looking at graph #2 for a shorter time period one again sees the steady decline in consumer credit.  Compare this to the early 90's where consumer credit levelled off but did not decline. 

In my opinion until the employment numbers start to seriously improve and home prices start creeping upwards we are going to see continued declines in consumer credit and thus sluggish growth (at best) in the overall economy.

Source: Federal Reserve

Monday, June 21, 2010

Total consumer debt continues falling

The Federal Reserve recently published the updated total consumer debt statistics.  Total consumer debt continues contracting and shows no sign of slowing its rate of decline.




As I have implied throughout my posts I believe we are in a debt deleveraging cycle right now.  (Look at the second graph for evidence)  Longer term this is healthy for the country to 'flush out' the excessive credit built up over time.  Unfortunately debt deleveraging means reducing ones current spending to repay all the previous spending (or defaulting on your debts)  Either way it detracts from current growth.

In previous posts and comments I have mentioned the difficulty of determining how much of the decline in consumer credit (a subset of consumer debt. Don't blame me for the lack of clearer descriptions) is due to lower spending versus higher charge offs.  Fortunately the Federal Reserve has done a little work on this very topic:
Notably, year-over-year growth in consumer loans adjusted for charge-offs has remained positive, which contrasts the negative growth in the as-reported series. That is, the net growth in new loans and loan repayments shows a positive (albeit slowing) growth rate once charge-offs are factored in. Over 2009, this estimate of charge-offs totaled about $27 billion while banks' average consumer loan balances declined by about $25 billion. Thus, a significant portion of the recent decline in consumer loan balances is the result of charge-offs.
This may explain consumer spending being more robust than the consumer credit numbers were showing.  The consumers are still buying, they are just unable to pay for it :) 

Friday, April 16, 2010

Some Friday Links -- Fun for all. A physics lesson tossed in as well.

Been busy with tax day but here's some links and comments . . .

Greece 10 year bond yields keep rising and are very close to piercing pre bailout yields. 
Some German profs are preparing a lawsuit.  -- Telegraph.co.uk
Has Greece hit the Chandrasekhar limit and just doesn't know it yet?  Once you go passed the limit there is no turning back.

Some back and forth on strategic defaults fueling consumer spending:
Pro Tinfoil: Creditwritedowns
Anti Tinfoil: The Big Picture

Creditwritedowns pulls together a lot of subjects and puts a nice bow on top describing a theory I agree with:  We are in a balance sheet recession that will not produce a strong rebound and will take a long time to reconcile.  I posted the Koo and Chanos videos recently but Mr. Harrison does more work tying it all together. 

Total copper inventories have now risen for 2 weeks straight and are close to penetrating their recent peak level; LME inventories have dramatically slowed their decline and Shanghai inventories hit new highs today.  Copper's getting smacked today.  I'll write more about this soon(tm).

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Popular media discovering where all those delinquent mortgage payments are going

I was going to blog about this yesterday afternoon but fundmymutualfund yet again scooped me on the entry and added his usual commentary to the matter.  As I have implied before the money NOT going to paying a mortgage is just being spent by Joe and Jane Consumer. 

Diana Olick of CNBC:

Okay, so 7.9 million Americans are not paying their mortgages.

Are we really thinking about the implications of that?
I've already reported studies that show Americans are now far more likely to pay their other bills first before their mortgage (which is a big turnaround historically speaking.)
That means they pay off their credit cards, cable bills, car loans in place of their home loans. Some are forced to, while others are doing so strategically. Don't get me started again on strategic defaults...
Paul Jackson, publisher of Housingwire.com, wrote a fascinating article last week that put this into real cash perspective.
First he describes a case study of someone who applied for the government's Home Affordable Modification Program.
The person had an $1,880.00 monthly mortgage payment on which they'd defaulted, but said person's monthly bank statement showed payments to a tanning salon, nail spa, liquor stores, DirecTV bill with premium charges, and $1,700.00 in retail purchases from The Gap, Old Navy, Home Depot, Sears, etc.
Writes Jackson:
Even if you assume that just half of the current 7.4 million currently delinquent mortgages fit this sort of ’spending profile’ (that is, they are spending their mortgage) and you assume a $1,000 median monthly mortgage payment for most U.S. homeowners — you get a $3.7 billion boost per month to consumer spending. It’s certainly enough spending to matter in the overall scheme of things.
To sum up the program as described by fundmymutualfund:

So for newer readers here is the 'game' as I've outlined many times.


1.Home'owners' default.. many of which are owners only in practice (not putting a dime down on their home).
2.That money once used to pay mortgages can now go into the economy as a form of permanent stimulus via consumption. Back in November I figured the number to be akin to the spring 2008 Bush stimulus - but instead of a 1x benefit, it's a permanent stimulus.
3.The banks drag feet on foreclosures because to make their balance sheet look good they will only take so many foreclosures over in any 1 quarter. Since the FASB (accounting board) rule change, they can do this since they don't have to mark the mortgages to reality - they can pretend... until of course the actual foreclosure. So the majority of mortgages on their books are still at "their discretion" and only the % they foreclose on, do they have to mark to "market" (i.e. reality). Hence the 6 months foreclosure now turns into the 18+ month foreclosure.
4.The market could care less about losses for large banks or the reality of the balance sheet because the US government stands behind all major banks... they are too big to fail. So the banks have nothing to worry about. Buy financial stocks - they are risk free, like Treasuries.
5.In the meantime Ben Bernanke will keep rates at 0% so the banks can "out earn" the losses. [Apr 20, 2009: How Banks Will "Outearn" Their Losses] Borrow from Fed at 0%, invest in anything (stocks, bonds...heck even do some loans), and make the spread. Use that 'free money' to offset foreclosure losses.
Presto magic!

So tell me what you think will happen to consumer spending when those 10% of people with late mortgages finally get kicked out of their homes and the banks are finally forced to realize the loss on the loan?  You wonder why the banks are not lending?  Extend and pretend only works so long. . .

Monday, April 12, 2010

Consumer credit continues dropping

Consumer credit continues falling.  The rate of decline appears to have stabilized but this means consumer credit continues to contract with no anticipated point of stabilitzation.





Longer term a deleveraged consumer is good news.  Getting there is not pleasant, whether it be from consumer paydowns or bank writing off debts.  As I have mentioned before the decline in consumer credit and debt prevents a strong recovery.  Not only is the added impulse of new debt (and thus spending) missing but the additional drag of debt reduction is still present.

After the inventory bounce recedes in the next 2 quarters GDP growth will remain muted in my opinion.

Monday, March 15, 2010

Total consumer debt continues falling & Consumer debt / GDP perspective

Total consumer debt statistics (all debt including home loans) came out recently and the credit decline continues.  I have produced a couple of graphs to provide some perspective on the data. 

Year over year consumer debt is still falling but at least we are no longer speeding up in our rate of decline.  Looking back you can also see we have not had a period of negative growth any time during the entire data series.

Observing total consumer debt to gdp (both in nominal terms) provides some interesting fodder for discussion. During the 1990's consumer debt / GDP rose <10%. Compare that to the 2000's where the growth rate was much faster. 

The consumer debt / gdp ratio has consistenly risen over the long term.  This ratio cannot rise forever!  Is parity where one starts to encounter serious problems? 

The Wall Street Journal ran a page one article regarding declining debt Friday, March 12 describing how defaults are reducing the total debt load of American consumers.

U.S. consumers are shedding debt at the fastest rate in more than six decades, largely through a wave of defaults, in a trend that underscores the depth of their financial troubles but could also help clear the way for a stronger economic recovery.


Total U.S. household debt, including mortgages and credit-card balances, fell 1.7% in 2009 to $13.5 trillion, the Federal Reserve reported Thursday—the first annual drop since records began in 1945. The debt amounts to $43,874 per U.S. resident.

While some of the decline is from consumer defaults, this is not a 'pain free' method of debt reduction.  Banks become capital deficient and reduce their lending when they take losses in excess of their models.

Longer term it is healthy for the economy to have a lower debt load but the path there is not easy.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Temporary workers increase year over year. Good news or a head fake?

Temporary worker employment has finally turned positive on a year over year basis.  Unfortunately this could be a head fake due to the current census temporary employment surge going on right now.  Fortunately the temporary census workers employment blitz should be over with before the usual seasonal peak in October / November.  If the seasonal peak of 2010 is above that of the previous year we may have a 'positive' bit of news to share with the world.

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Consumer credit keeps contracting faster

Consumer credit data came out about 2 weeks ago and the numbers are not getting any better.  Unlike my previous entries showing the very long term I thought I'd zoom in a little to show you how this recession is unlike anything we've seen in the last 40 years.  Consumer credit keeps going down and the rate of declining is increasing.  Call this an anti-'green shoot'.

The economy will not properly recover and the Federal Reserve will most likely not raise interest rates too much (if at all) until consumer credit and bank lending start rising.  Until then, get used to very low short term rates.

Monday, February 1, 2010

Mortgage Delinquencies -- A real hockey stick graph

Mortgage delinquencies keep rising nationwide as reported by Freddie Mac & Fannie Mae (via Calculatedrisk blog)

Until the delinquency rate starts to fall I seriously doubt home prices or new home construction will do anything beyond stumble along.

One hidden benefit from all the loans going bad is pre payment speeds have sped up for various mortgage backed securities.  I have noticed a bump in principal paydowns beyond normal and I think its all the mortgages being purchased out of pools by the GSE's.  Considering I own a wad of leveraged inverse floaters at below par I'm happy with that.

Friday, January 29, 2010

Temporary Workers -- less worse

I know I know, I'm a bit late in producing this but I've been busy the last few weeks and the usual charts and graphs data feed has fallen to the wayside a bit.

Employment data came out a while ago and the temporary employment subsection showed some improvement in the famous 'second derivative' department. 

Unlike some other people who look at seasonally adjusted data I prefer to look at the non seasonally adjusted series, noise and all. 

December was higher than November, which is unusual.  It could be later hiring for the Christmas rush or the census hiring hitting.  As such the yoy% change was a bit higher than I expected.

 I have added a new line to the graph 'min max average'.  This line is constructed by averaging the max point over the last 14 months and  the minimum data point over the last 14 months.  I use 14 months because the peak and valley for temporary employment can each sometimes vary by a month.  Generally this min max average and the %yoy change confirm each others movements but I thought looking at the data a slightly different way would be interesting.  The min max average continues to drop.

Census hiring is supposed to peak during the summer months and thus hopefully not screw up this data series too much.  Right now it is showing a 'less worse' situation but still NO growth. 

Wednesday, December 30, 2009

Home mortgage delinquency rates keep rising


Delinquency rates keep rising for home mortgages. Calculatedrisk blog provides the details and they are universally not good.  As you can see from the chart, delinquency rates have skyrocketed and are not slowing down. 

If you have sensed a bit of bearishness throughout my blog entries so far, this hockey stick graph is one of the reasons. (I'm not always a pessimist, really)  Rising delinquency rates are one of the impediments to a healthy growing economy.

Monday, December 7, 2009

Consumer credit, where art thou?


Consumer credit (consumer loans excluding home loans) was released today.  Consumer credit continues to contract further and faster.  Unlike my previous posting I have extended the graph back to the beginning of the data series so you can see the extent of the current decline in context.

Since World War II at worst consumer credit levelled off for a period of time before resuming its ascent.  Not this time.  While you may not be able to see it, the current rate of decline is getting worse each month and shows no sign of at least slowing down.